Discussion about this post

User's avatar
H Y's avatar

I think this is a great piece on society and your perspective of the world we live in today. Hopefully what I’m about to say speaks to that. People grow up chasing titles and positions and they miss their calling on life. I think school has its place in society and roles as well. Let me ask you this would you like a doctor who has passed his classes to work on you or a doctor who hasn’t passed 1st grade. Now the one who hasn’t passed first grade may be a better doctor but school gives you some insight on what they know and what they are capable of. I personally would much rather the better doctor who is horrible at being a good person than a doctor who is an amazing person but killed 20 people do to the lack of technical skill. A lot of ways to spin it. Do I diss again with you no not at all but is there another side to your idea yes.

Expand full comment
Lucy's avatar

I think most of the observations made are broadly true. However, saying this they veer towards cliche and do not take much account of complexity and nuance. It is understandable that the writer might want to pass on the message - be a good person - it is a lot better than being a bad one, after all. Rarely do we see much hopeful writing that acknowledges the manifest unfairness of the world and its ways. Most of this is playing towards peoples' prejudices - the good end happily if you like. It is acceptable if the broad aim is the improvement of adolescents, however if it is an understanding of the human condition: the whys and wherefores of our flawed societies and generally conflict riven world, maybe this sort of writing is not so helpful. Why must there be metrics for adult professionals? I thought the point of being an adult professional was that a person was trusted to do their job to the best of their ability - that is why there is schools of higher education and professional qualifications. Who gets to decide what the metrics are? To the fairly causal writer - yes I do have post graduate qualifications but I am writing this off the cuff - it seems as if it is Samuel Smiles for bright teenage boys. There is nothing wrong with that, necessarily, but context is often expected as given. I hope that who ever read this note finds it helpful.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts